You play taking turns clockwise. The game is played in 3 rounds. Each round includes 2 phases :
During the casting phase, you gather tiles to the rhythm of the soundtrack : place the MonStars on one of the three zones of the stage at the top. The jury members sit on their chairs.
At the applause phase, at the end of each round, your goal is for your MonStar tiles to show as many talent symbols as correspond to those your jury likes. Each match gives you a popularity point, which you can mark on the applause meter with your spider score marker.
Casting phase: gather tiles
You all have the same chances to place tiles to fill your stage (= MonStar tiles and Jury tiles), and this until the end of the round. However, during the first round, an jury spot must remain empty. Indeed, there is always a late monster who arrives after the start of the show!
Who among you is the most horrible? You start the first round. Start the soundtrack.
When you hear a tense breath in the soundtrack, you must flip a tile. When the buzzer and the cheer sound, you can take a face-up tile and place it on your stage. At the next breath, the turn passes immediately to the person on your left. From that moment on, you can no longer take tiles, place any, nor move any on your stage.
Warning : it is important that you pay close attention to the soundtrack's audio cues (breath and buzzer)! If you don't hear them or ignore them, you'll quickly get lost and might forget someone. Fairness is the golden rule in The New MonStar (it even comes before the ban on devouring the audience!).
As soon as the thunder of applause, the casting phase is over. You can then stop the soundtrack.
Applause phase: earn popularity points
The time has come to party with your MonStars! After the casting phase, you are greeted (hopefully!) by a burst of applause, which earns you popularity points.
Go through all the tiles on your stage. Proceed as follows:
Return duplicates:
there can be only one copy of each tile (MonStar or Jury) on your stage. Choose one tile for each character and return duplicates to the middle of the table.
Flip misplaced MonStars : is a MonStar tile not in the correct zone of the stage (see spotlight symbol)? Flip it.
Count the popularity points:
Compare the talent symbols of your MonStar tiles with those of your jury. Each talent symbol matching to the jury gives you 1 popularity point.flipped costs you 1 popularity point.
Advance the spider score marker
: on the applause meter, move your spider score marker forward by the number of points obtained. As soon as you pass number 30 at the star, flip your spider to the star side. It then indicates that you have already collected 30 popularity points.

Once you have advanced your spiders, all the tiles from your stage are returned to the middle of the table. Turn all tiles face-down, shuffle them well, then randomly flip 6 of them face-up.
Restart the soundtrack. The player to the left of the most horrible one starts.